Scaffolding Autonomy: Rethinking the Right to Opt Out of Health Data’s Secondary Use in the EHDS

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15168/2284-4503-4367

Keywords:

self-determination, right to opt out, scaffolded autonomy, secondary use of health data, privacy assistants

Abstract

The European Health Data Space (EHDS) grants a right to opt out of health data’s secondary use through an accessible, user-friendly mechanism. While rightly recognizing that legalistic disclosure fails to enable informed decision-making, the EHDS cannot resolve the problem through usability alone. This article argues the deeper failure is conceptual: data protection law conflates autonomy with information transparency and control over data, neglecting decision-making’s scaffolded nature. Unequal literacy, an opt-out functioning as a de facto default, and weak redress expose some individuals disproportionately to the impossibility to exercise that autonomy and to more severe harm. Drawing on the concept of scaffolded autonomy from medical ethics, the article reconceives secondary-use decisions as a continuous, supported process in which, under appropriate safeguards, AI can serve as a cognitive boost.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-31

Issue

Section

Essays

How to Cite

Rossi, A. (2026). Scaffolding Autonomy: Rethinking the Right to Opt Out of Health Data’s Secondary Use in the EHDS. BioLaw Journal - Rivista Di BioDiritto, 3, 191-217. https://doi.org/10.15168/2284-4503-4367