From Autonomy to Responsibility: A Levinasian Account of Relational Decision-Making in Healthcare in England and Wales

Autori

  • Ilaria Bertini Bios Centre, Londra

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.15168/2284-4503-4364

Parole chiave:

patient autonomy, paternalism, relational autonomy, Emmanuel Levinas, english case law

Abstract

This paper examines patient autonomy, exploring its legal and ethical dimensions with a particular focus on England and Wales. It argues that the dominant view of autonomy as individual choice is too narrow and overlooks the relational and moral contexts. Drawing on British case law and the shift from medical paternalism to patient-centred care, the paper argues for a more nuanced, relational understanding of autonomy. Using the approach of Emmanuel Levinas, it emphasises vulnerability, responsibility and ethical obligations in human encounters. A Levinasian understanding of relational autonomy therefore shifts the focus of clinical ethics from protecting isolated choice to cultivating relationships of responsibility in which both patients and healthcare professionals can cooperate in the interests of better outcomes. Autonomy is reconceived as relational, grounded in care and interdependence. It is the fruit of an ethical encounter in which the patient and clinician together seek what is genuinely good for the person whose life is at stake.

Pubblicato

2026-10-31

Fascicolo

Sezione

Saggi

Come citare

Bertini, I. (2026). From Autonomy to Responsibility: A Levinasian Account of Relational Decision-Making in Healthcare in England and Wales. BioLaw Journal - Rivista di BioDiritto, 3, 127-142. https://doi.org/10.15168/2284-4503-4364

Altri articoli dello/a stesso/a autore/rice